Section iii presents the results for the simulation exercise. The entire exante evaluation process was truly interactive and also iterative. Types of evaluation monitoring and evaluation blog. Exante policy impact assessment includes five consecutive steps, namely. The context of the rise of ex ante evaluation patricia popelier and victoria verlinden 3. A practical guide on ex ante evaluation for research infrastructures. Reviewing criticism of other approaches, such as scenarios and computerbased. Ex ante project evaluation and the complexity of early decision. A s promised in the preface,this books approach is to give you a barebones, nutsandbolts guide about how to do an evaluation. Ex ante evaluation entails predictive evaluation of the design effort with regard to the future impacts, whereas expost evaluation evaluates both financial and nonfinancial values of a developed. The first step of the programme exante evaluation is the evaluation of ope 20142020 strategy. One states that evaluation is ex post and that socalled ex ante evaluation is a forecast. This type of evaluation, also referred to as a baseline survey, is carried out before an actual project is implemented.
Nonie guidelines on impact evaluation adopts the oecddac definition of impact while referring to the techniques used to attribute impact to an intervention as necessarily based on counterfactual analysis. Chapter 2 issues in exante and expost evaluations jica. The oecd reference guide this is not a stepbystep guide on how to perform an expost evaluation, and it does not suggest a specific approach on how to undertake one. Does an upstream firm have a right to use a rivers water or does a downstream firm have a right not to have the water used. An introduction jonathan verschuuren and rob van gestel i context of ex ante evaluation 2. The exante evaluation of the interreg europe programme 20142020 combined various methods and techniques which are mainly relating to theorybased evaluation and especially to programme theory. The use of historical returns has customarily been the most wellknown approach to forecast the probability of.
The ex ante evaluation exante of the rop of macedonia thrace 200720 was prepared under the guidelines from the ministry of economy, competitiveness and shipping and under the context determined both from the relative working document of the european commission and the general regulation on structural funds. The impact of legislation a critical analysis of ex ante. Ex ante evaluation of legislation torn among its rationales pierre larouche 4. Methodologies for impact assessment in the ex ante evaluation of. Another example is the council recommendation on the prevention and reduction of healthrelated harm associated with drug dependence, 10 adopted on 18 june 2003, which highlights the need to develop both ex ante and ex post evaluation to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of drug prevention and the reduction of drugrelated health risks. It must however be stressed that this forms an integral part of the exante evaluation. However, opinion varies on the meaning of the quality of a decision base. What is missing from the term impact evaluation is the way impact shows up longterm. James, your question has started an interesting conversation i was not about to answer it on my own. Methodological handbook for implementing an exante assessment of agriculture financial instruments under the eafrd glossary, acronyms and definition of terms 5 expression explanation csf the common strategic framework translates the objectives and targets of the eu strategy for smart, sustainable inclusive growth into key actions for the esi funds. An example of an expost evaluation using more than one counterfactual 22.
This paper discusses methods for evaluating the impacts of social programs prior to their implementation. Ex ante and ex post evaluations cambridge university press. Implementing genderaware ex ante evaluations to maximize. In trying to learn more about sustainable development solutions, the first place to look for information is in expost evaluations, also commonly called postproject evaluations, which are conducted by either development organizations themselves or by independent external evaluators. The strategy should follow the general intervention logic of the operational programmes set by regulation ec 320 of the european parliament and of the council of 17 december 20. The key role of the exante evaluation is to contribute to the development of an emff op which is in line with the needs of the member state on the one hand and with eu wide priorities on the other hand. Ex ante evaluation is useful for designing programs that achieve some optimality criteria, such as maximizing impact for a given cost. In section iv results from a conventional ex post evaluation are presented and related to similar findings in the literature. Pdf methodologies for impact assessment in the ex ante. This chapter of the evaluation guidelines uses example cases to explain mainly the methods for examining the project concepts that were planned through these. For many reasons, it is important to develop tools for ex ante evaluation of social programs. It shows that most observations and suggestions formulated by the exante evaluators have been.
In this paper, we illustrate through several examples how to. What managing authorities need to know before starting the exante assessment 20 1. Whilst the companys prime focus is in respect to fisheries, the components of the evaluation process conform to ec guideline notes. Designing evaluation questions, methods, and tools 8. The other evaluation problem is the exante evaluation problem, which begins with an explicit understanding that the program that was actually run may not be the one that corresponds to a particular policy of interest. Guidelines for the exante evaluation of 20142020 emff ops updated march 2014 this document is based on the consolidated version cod 2011 0380 of 10 february 2014 of the amended proposal for a regulation of the european parliament and the council on the european. First, ex ante evaluation of a range of programs makes it possible to optimally design a program that achieves some desired impacts at a minimum cost or maximizes impacts for a given cost. This course will examine econometric methods for evaluating effects of program interventions. Ex ante evaluation provides strategic information about the main. Methodological guide on exante assessment of the impact of. Exante evaluations have been performed for all oda loan projects that have been appraised since fy2001, and the results have been released as exante evaluation reports immediately after the conclusion of loan agreement.
Ex ante project evaluation and the complexity of early. Exante, derived from the latin for before the event, is a term that refers to future events, such as future returns or prospects of a company. Understanding implementation, managing adaptively, and learning asseins sg invnreetiont s 7. One states that evaluation is expost and that socalled exante evaluation is a forecast. Ex ante evaluation of social programs by petra todd. An ex ante evaluation uses data to predict the impact of a policy or programme prior to its implementation, in contrast to an ex post evaluation, which investigates outcomes after a policy has been implemented. These findings suggest two primary challenges for the world bank. Firstly, the fed is raising interest rates in the us because. Ex post definition is based on knowledge and retrospection and being essentially objective and factual opposed to ex ante. Critically, ex ante and inproject assessments can help inform what is needed to ensure that the potential benefits of an activity actually materialise to identify the preconditions for project success.
How ifc measures the development impact of its interventions. Typical interventions that might be of interest include job training or other active. Methodological handbook for implementing an exante assessment of agriculture financial instruments under the eafrd 1 table of contents glossary, acronyms and definition of terms 4 i. Trying to maintain a strict boundary between ex post impact assessment and evaluation is probably not useful except for didactic purposes. More commonly, considerable resources are used on detailed planning of a single, specific solution, whereas alternatives are not or are inadequately assessed early on. This is part of the needs analysis and planning activity of the. Comparison of policy options and selection of the best one pia steps at the level of line ministries can be illustrated as follows. These types of evaluation are formative evaluation, midterm evaluation, summative evaluation, expost evaluation and meta evaluation.
Exante evaluation assesses whether objectives are clear, coherent and adjusted to the situation, helps the realistic numeric quantification of these and defines indicators enabling the monitoring of implementation, as well as reporting on results achieved. Reference guide on expost evaluation of competition. Even if we regard ex post evaluations to be more reliable for estimating treatment impacts of an existing program, there is still a critical role for ex ante evaluation tools. Outline of funding mechanisms and definition of the budget government.
Purpose the aim of this article is to introduce business wargaming as a tool for ex ante strategy evaluation. The degree of interaction depends largely on the enthusiasm of government officials that participate and the evaluators. Following an activity ex post to assess whether or by how much an activity improved the quality of life figure 2. Exante evaluation exante evaluations have been performed for all oda loan projects that have been appraised since fy2001, and the results have been released as exante evaluation reports immediately after the conclusion of loan agreement. Methodological handbook for implementing an exante. Scope and purpose of the exante assessment for fi 15 iii. Chapter 2 issues in exante and expost evaluations evaluation study, and also shows example case in project evaluations, examinations are basically conducted in view of all five evaluation criteria, but depending on the timing of the evaluation study, the perception of each issue is different. Expost is another word for actual returns and is latin for after the fact. The aimm system thus connects 1 diagnostics to 2 exante project selectionscoring, which is tied to 3 results measurement during portfolio supervision and, ultimately, to 4 expost evaluation. The standard process of exante evaluations is well documented.
Pdf the ex ante quantification of impactsis compulsory when establishing a rural. Exante evaluations to examine the interpretation by national regional governments uk countries and denmark of the fifg fisheries structural regulation. How good are ex ante program evaluation techniques. What can we learn from expost postproject evaluations. A framework for the exante evaluation of erp software. There is an example of ex ante and ex post in this blog from paul krugman below about the decision of the fed to raise interest rates. Ex ante evaluation is a broad initial assessment aimed at identifying which alternative will yield the greatest benefit from an intended investment. Ex ante investments and ex post externalities lucian arye bebchuk abstract whenever the use of an asset by one party imposes an externality on another partys use of an asset, entitlements must be allocated. Moreover, the exante evaluation plays a practical role in relation to the delivery and evaluation of the programme. A second position is that human systems and natural systems dont evolve at the same pace and that what is ex post in human systems may well be ex ante in natural systems suggesting that the distinction is artificial. Ex ante evaluation of proposed interventions manangginvinreetiont s 5. The exante evaluation provides information to serve as a basis for monitoring and evaluation after starting a project and is an indispensable step to the appropriate management of a project throughout the project cycle. We than andrew foster and susan parker for helpful comments.
54 601 1299 1521 602 1301 675 1134 1442 15 1128 828 1110 671 759 1400 866 1046 1380 199 162 1287 138 1008 959 1005 1096 1364 324 295 671 141 748 206 135 146 144 111 914 1052 426 598 469 1069 1119 1112 35 575 86